Paulie Gee's Paulie Gee's
  • Home
  • Menu
  • About
  • Photos
  • Reviews
  • Location
  • Paulie Gee's


    1195 N High St, Columbus, OH 43201, United States


  • Paulie Gee's


    +1 614-808-0112


Service options

+ Delivery

+ Takeaway

+ Dine-in

Highlights

+ Fast service

+ Great beer selection

+ Great cocktails

+ Great wine list

Popular for

+ Lunch

+ Dinner

+ Solo dining

Accessibility

+ Wheelchair-accessible car park

+ Wheelchair-accessible entrance

+ Wheelchair-accessible seating

+ Wheelchair-accessible toilet

Offerings

+ Alcohol

+ Beer

+ Cocktails

+ Coffee

+ Comfort food

+ Happy-hour drinks

+ Happy-hour food

+ Spirits

+ Vegan options

+ Vegetarian options

+ Wine

Dining options

+ Lunch

+ Dinner

+ Dessert

+ Seating

+ Table service

Amenities

+ Bar on site

+ Toilet

Atmosphere

+ Casual

+ Cosy

+ Trendy

Crowd

+ Groups

+ Tourists

+ University students

Planning

+ Accepts reservations

Payments

+ Credit cards

+ Debit cards

+ NFC mobile payments

+ Credit cards

Children

+ High chairs

Parking

+ Paid parking lot

+ Paid street parking

+ Parking


Paulie Gee's menu

Pepperoni Square

Cheddar edge, mozzarella, oregano, Ezzo pepperoni, red sauce, basil, parmesan, Mike's hot honey limited availability.

US$28.00

Pep And Sausage Square

Cheddar edge, mozzarella, garlic, sausage, Ezzo pepperoni, ricotta, basil, Mike's hot honey, red sauce, parmesan limited availability.

US$30.00

The Donna Square

Cheddar edge, shaved garlic, mozzarella, Ezzo pepperoni, pre oven honey, goat cheese, basil, cracked black pepper.

US$30.00

Cacio E Pepe Square

Mozzarella, aged mozzarella, parmigiano, pecorino, garlic, EVOO, burrata, cracked black pepper limited availability.

US$28.00

Pep & Burrata Square

Cheddar edge, aged mozzarella, fresh mozzarella, Ezzo pepperoni, burrata, basil, Mike's hot honey, parmigiano reggiano limited availability.

US$30.00

Cheese Square

Cheddar edge, mozzarella, oregano, red sauce, basil, parmesan, Mike's hot honey limited availability.

US$26.00

Jeb's Garden

Vegan. Italian tomatoes, garlic, spinach, red onion, mushroom, red pepper flake, sesame seeds, housemade cashew ricotta, chili oil, maldon sea salt.

US$22.00

Vegan Supreme

Vegan. Italian tomatoes, garlic, mushroom, red onion, EVOO, housemade cashew ricotta, Maldon sea salt.

US$21.00

Full Menu

Discover Paulie Gee's

Paulie Gee's on 1195 N High St, Columbus, OH 43201, is a must-visit spot for pizza lovers who crave something extraordinary. Located in the heart of the city, this cozy pizzeria combines the perfect balance of delicious food, friendly service, and a vibrant atmosphere. Whether you're a local or just visiting, Paulie Gee's offers an unforgettable dining experience that will keep you coming back for more.

As soon as you step inside, the rustic, yet modern décor sets the mood for a casual meal with friends or family. The open kitchen adds to the excitement, allowing diners to watch their pizzas being prepared with care and precision. The atmosphere is warm and inviting, with a mix of wooden tables and stylish lighting that creates a relaxed vibe, perfect for any occasion.

The real star of the show, however, is the pizza. Paulie Gee's menu is a testament to the art of pizza-making, offering a variety of unique and mouthwatering pies. The crust is perfectly crisp, with just the right amount of chewiness, and the toppings are always fresh and flavorful. A standout choice is the “Hellboy” pizza, which features spicy soppressata, fresh mozzarella, and a drizzle of hot honey that adds a surprising sweetness. Another fan favorite is the “Greenpointer,” a veggie-packed pizza with roasted mushrooms, spinach, and ricotta, making it a hit among vegetarians and meat-eaters alike.

For those who prefer to customize their pizza, Paulie Gee's also offers a build-your-own option. With a wide array of toppings, from traditional pepperoni to exotic choices like smoked mozzarella and truffle oil, you're guaranteed to find the perfect combination. The beauty of Paulie Gee's is in its versatility - there's something on the menu for every taste preference.

Not just limited to pizza, Paulie Gee's also serves a range of other dishes that complement the main attraction. The appetizer menu includes tempting options like the crispy, golden-brown fried calamari, paired with a zesty marinara dipping sauce. The seasonal salads are another great choice, offering fresh, crunchy vegetables tossed in house-made dressings that are light but flavorful.

And let’s not forget the drink menu. Whether you're in the mood for a craft beer, a glass of wine, or a classic cocktail, Paulie Gee's has it all. The bar area is stocked with a selection of local brews, as well as wines that pair beautifully with the pizzas. The cocktails are expertly crafted, with options like the “Basil Smash,” a refreshing mix of gin, basil, and lemon that perfectly complements the flavors of the food.

Customer service at Paulie Gee's is top-notch, with friendly staff who are knowledgeable about the menu and always ready to make recommendations. The service is fast without feeling rushed, allowing diners to enjoy their meal at their own pace.

In terms of pricing, Paulie Gee's offers great value for the quality of food served. The pizzas are generously sized, making it easy to share with a group or save leftovers for later. With reasonable prices and an extensive menu, it's a great spot for both casual diners and those looking for a more refined pizza experience.

The location at 1195 N High St places Paulie Gee's in a prime spot for both locals and tourists. Columbus has a thriving food scene, and this pizzeria stands out for its dedication to crafting delicious, innovative pies. Whether you're grabbing a quick bite or sitting down for a leisurely meal, Paulie Gee's offers a welcoming space that will make you feel right at home.

If you're in the area and looking for a new place to grab a bite, Paulie Gee's is definitely worth checking out. With its inviting ambiance, diverse menu, and exceptional service, it’s clear why this pizzeria has become a beloved destination for pizza enthusiasts in Columbus. Whether you're a first-timer or a regular, you’re guaranteed to leave satisfied, with a full stomach and a smile on your face.


Paulie Gee's Photos

Paulie Gee's Photo -1
Paulie Gee's Photo -2
Paulie Gee's Photo -3
Paulie Gee's Photo -4
Paulie Gee's Photo -5
Paulie Gee's Photo -6
Paulie Gee's Photo -7
Paulie Gee's Photo -8
Paulie Gee's Photo -9
Paulie Gee's Photo -10

Location & Contact

Get in touch with our support team


  • 1195 N High St, Columbus, OH 43201, United States
  • +1 614-808-0112




Clock


Hours

Our open schedules

Day
Monday Closed
Tuesday 04:00 PM - 10:00 PM
Wednesday 04:00 PM - 10:00 PM
Thursday 04:00 PM - 10:00 PM
Friday 03:00 PM - 10:00 PM
Saturday 03:00 PM - 10:00 PM
Sunday 03:00 PM - 09:00 PM



Reviews

  • Just an amazing meal. The pizza is to die for. Top 3 of all the margheritas we have had. And another (forgot the name) was just as good. A must-visit for sure.

    Thomas Allen
  • !⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐! Paulie Gee’s Columbus is absolutely amazing. The Just Like Heaven pizza was perfectly made — not soggy at all, with the perfect chewiness. Every bite was balanced and delicious. It was so good I came back twice in one week, which says everything. Easily one of the best pizzas in Columbus. Can’t wait to go back again.

    Bobby Truong
  • This place has the best vegan pizza we've ever had. The crust/dough is phenomenal--so good they have a unique item (the dough pillow, which can be vegan if you sub the butter for olive oil) so you can eat it by itself! We got the vegan ricotta, sausage and arugula pizza, which was amazing. The ricotta was particularly good. I can't believe they weren't packed at lunchtime on a Saturday! Bobby took care of us and was super attentive. We'll definitely be back!

    Samantha Baxter
  • Probably the best pizza I've had outside the Northeast. The dough on both the round and square pizzas are top notch. There's a stark difference but they're both peak. Went for the Greenpointer to have the illusion of health on top of the stacked Cacio de Pepe and it was surprisingly good for an arugula topped pizza.

    Khalid Abusamieh
  • Finally tried Paulie Gee’s after quite a few folks have suggested it on our quest to find some great pizza in OH. Did NOT disappoint! The Square was phenomenal, flavour, quality, and texture all came together for a perfectly scrumptious slice. We also got the hellboywhite pizza, again fantastic and fresh ingredients… but it really was the pizza square that will keep me up at night till i get another!

    Rachel Barich
  • I’ve eaten plenty of pizza in my life, including many Detroit style pizzas since I live in Michigan. Paulie Gee’s square pizza was the best pizza I have ever had in my life, swear to god. We had the pepperoni and burrata one and we fought over the last piece. Absolutely incredible. The place fills up so get there early but it is worth any wait I promise you. Prompt & friendly service as well but the square pizza is the star here.

    Jessica Wilson
  • I went to Paulie Gee’s for the first time tonight but I e been to many other pizza places in Columbus before. I can co directly say this is the best pizza in Columbus. THE CRUST! Its chefs kiss perfect. It has good structure but also gives a little and has good ratio with toppings. Wood fired adds a delightful taste and crisp. One of the people I dined with got a deep dish and I was very impressed with this as well- super crispy cheese on the edges, and well incredible. I’m not sure if I’ll do a deep dish or a traditional next time Because they are both so good. The only criticism I’d say is we ordered the Caesar salad and it really was quite spicy and I didn’t expect it. I wish they had more sides and maybe even a dessert menu but they do pizza extremely well so I’m glad they at least do that and offer a lot of variety in terms of toppings and crust type! I’ve heard to get the true deliciousness you should done in and not take this to go! I’ll be thinking about this pizza for a long time! 3/2/24: weeks came back a second time. Service was excellent but the deep dish was a little over cooked (burnt) on the bottom and was a bit disappointing.

    Grant Donnelly
  • Paulie Gee’s has the best vegan pizza in town IMHO and they have 3 pies for $45 on Wednesdays. Pictured. Jeb’s garden. Simply red. In ricotta da Vida. Vegan supreme

    Goose Rodriguez

Explore More Taste

  • 331 Reviews

    A Taste Of Thailand Restaurant

    A Taste Of Thailand Restaurant

    Thai Restaurant

    1933 Stumpf Boulevard Suite -A Terrytown, Gretna, LA 70056, United States

  • 101 Reviews

    Kushitoro

    Kushitoro

    Izakaya Restaurant

    Japan, 〒106-0032 Tokyo, Minato City, Roppongi, 7 Chome−12−3 Power House Roppongi, 1F

  • 170 Reviews

    Mageirio Tavernaki

    Mageirio Tavernaki

    Restaurant

    Eleftherias 121, Limassol 3042, Cyprus

  • 1535 Reviews

    Kisaki Ramen & Sushi

    Kisaki Ramen & Sushi

    Japanese Restaurant

    Piazza Capranica, 75, 00186 Roma RM, Italy

  • 902 Reviews

    La Déliciosa

    La Déliciosa

    Coffee Shop

    Av. 16 Novembre, Rabat, Morocco

Paulie Gee's

Discover the bold, wood-fired flavors of Paulie Gee's in Columbus! This cozy spot serves up creative, handcrafted pizzas that keep locals coming back for more.

The information here is community-driven and not from an official source. If you are the site owner, we welcome you to contact us.