Gina's Gem
Baked cheese dip with speck, roasted garlic, Mike's hot honey, served with housemade focaccia.
Out Together
Local greens, cucumber, red pepper, leeks, tomato, ditalini, lemon parmigiano dressing.
Dough Pillow
Wood-fired bread with rotating butter.
The Cae-Sal
Romaine, peppadew peppers, toasted breadcrumbs, parmesan, Caesar dressing.
Joe Peppitoni
Italian tomatoes, fresh mozzarella, parmigiano reggiano, Ezzo pepperoni.
Cherry Jones
Fresh mozzarella, gorgonzola, prosciutto, dried bing cherries, orange blossom honey.
Trustfall
Chef's choice! Always something creative that's not on the menu!
The Supreme
Italian tomatoes, fresh mozzarella, Ezzo pepperoni, sweet Italian fennel sausage, cremini mushrooms, green pepper, sliced red onion.
The Big Cheesy
Italian tomatoes, garlic, parmigiano reggiano, aged mozzarella, fresh mozzarella, oregano, EVOO.
Greenpointer
Fresh mozzarella, arugula, EVOO, lemon juice, shaved parmigiano reggiano.
Cacio E Pepe
Fresh mozzarella, aged mozzarella, parmigiano reggiano, pecorino romano, garlic, EVOO, burrata, cracked black pepper.
Swellboy
Fresh mozzarella, hot soppressata, goat cheese, peppadew peppers, orange blossom honey.
Regina
Italian tomatoes, fresh mozzarella, pecorino romano, EVOO, basil.
Just Like Heaven
Mozzarella, cooper's sharp cheddar. Crispy speck, honey, black pepper.
Hellified Porkpie White
Fresh mozzarella, hot soppressata, sweet Italian fennel sausage, basil, red onion, sliced garlic, Mike's hot honey drizzle.
Ricky Too
Italian tomatoes, fresh mozzarella, sweet Italian fennel sausage, Ezzo pepperoni, pecorino romano, post-oven ricotta, arugula, EVOO.
The Donna
Aged mozzarella, fresh mozzarella, garlic, basil, pepperoni, goat cheese, black pepper, Mike's hot honey.
Hellboy
Italian tomatoes, hot soppressata, fresh mozzarella, parmigiano reggiano, Mike's hot honey drizzle.
Simple & Red
Vegan. Italian tomatoes, garlic, basil, cashew ricotta, black mission fig balsamic, Maldon sea salt.
In Ricotta Da Vegan
Vegan. Italian tomatoes, housemade vegan sausage, baby arugula, housemade cashew ricotta, EVOO, Maldon sea salt.
Vegan Supreme
Vegan. Italian tomatoes, garlic, mushroom, red onion, EVOO, housemade cashew ricotta, Maldon sea salt.
Jeb's Garden
Vegan. Italian tomatoes, garlic, spinach, red onion, mushroom, red pepper flake, sesame seeds, housemade cashew ricotta, chili oil, maldon sea salt.
Cheese Square
Cheddar edge, mozzarella, oregano, red sauce, basil, parmesan, Mike's hot honey limited availability.
Pep & Burrata Square
Cheddar edge, aged mozzarella, fresh mozzarella, Ezzo pepperoni, burrata, basil, Mike's hot honey, parmigiano reggiano limited availability.
Cacio E Pepe Square
Mozzarella, aged mozzarella, parmigiano, pecorino, garlic, EVOO, burrata, cracked black pepper limited availability.
The Donna Square
Cheddar edge, shaved garlic, mozzarella, Ezzo pepperoni, pre oven honey, goat cheese, basil, cracked black pepper.
Pep And Sausage Square
Cheddar edge, mozzarella, garlic, sausage, Ezzo pepperoni, ricotta, basil, Mike's hot honey, red sauce, parmesan limited availability.
Pepperoni Square
Cheddar edge, mozzarella, oregano, Ezzo pepperoni, red sauce, basil, parmesan, Mike's hot honey limited availability.
If you’re browsing Paulie Gee's Menu at 1195 N High St in Columbus, you’re in for something way beyond your average pizza night. The first thing that jumps out is the creativity. Sure, you’ll find the classics, but it’s the unexpected combinations that really steal the show. Think perfectly blistered crusts with toppings that balance smoky, sweet, spicy, and creamy all at once. Every pie feels thoughtfully put together, not just tossed on for the sake of it.
And it’s not just pizza. There are fresh salads that actually feel satisfying, shareable starters that make the table go quiet for a minute, and vegan options that don’t feel like an afterthought. The ingredients taste fresh, the flavors are bold without being overwhelming, and there’s something comforting about the whole lineup. Whether you’re here for a laid-back dinner with friends or just craving a slice that hits differently, the variety makes it easy to find a favorite-or three.